Embattled judge defends his record

Local News

June 3, 2009

By Kandra Wells The McAlester News-Capital Wed Jun 03, 2009, 10:24 AM CDT

A judge who was denounced last week on a national cable television program over a sentence in a child rape case helped establish a local center for child victims of abuse and was a state honoree for his work with children in courts.

“I uphold the law of the state,” District 18 Judge Thomas Bartheld said Monday. “No matter what you do, I would not tolerate a child being traumatized in my courtroom.”

Bartheld was lambasted last week by Bill O’Reilly and Geraldo Rivera during a segment of “The O’Reilly Factor,” a Fox News program. “This judge should be thrown off the bench immediately,” O’Reilly said, referring to the judge’s supposed ruling in the David Harold E. Earls rape case.

Last month, Bartheld was honored by the Pittsburg County Child Abuse Response Effort (PC-CARE), which includes an advocacy center where young crime victims can be examined and interviewed in a child-friendly environment. Interviews are recorded on video so a child only has to be interviewed once, and physical exams can be done on site, if necessary, so that young victims don’t have to go to a public clinic or hospital.

Bartheld said the center was established based on work he began more than 10 years ago.

“What they’ve done (at PC-CARE) since then is miraculous and marvelous,” the judge said. “But that PC-CARE unit came about because I called some people together.”

A judge since 1995, Bartheld said he saw the need for the center because of the child abuse cases coming through his courtroom.

“What was happening is kids were getting interviewed by DHS (the state Department of Human Services), then the police, then the medical personnel,” Bartheld said. “It puts the children through more trauma each time.”

The judge was also recognized by the state’s CASA program, Court Appointed Special Advocate. CASA assigns volunteer advocates to represent the children involved in various cases. The advocates might visit with the child in a case at home or school, and then report their findings to a judge, independent of findings by another agency, such as DHS or police.

In 2002, the judge said he was named Judge of the Year for Oklahoma by CASA.

Bartheld also deals with children in his courtroom for divorce and custody cases. One lawyer who was in a courtroom for one of those cases vividly remembers Bartheld.

“I had numerous custody matters in his court, and he was always particularly careful about the rights of children,” said Debra K. Lumpkins, an assistant attorney general with the Consumer Protection Division for the Attorney General of Missouri. “The one time I can remember that I was surprised at his vehemence was when I used the phrase ‘standard visitation.’

“He told me nothing to do with children in his court was treated as standard, and that he did the best he knew for each individual child.”

According to Lumpkins, O’Reilly and Rivera picked the wrong target for their program.

“Judge Bartheld does not deserve it,” she said.

Text Only

Local News

Council to look again at releasing $700,000 to McAlester Public Schools
City councilors are expected to take a look at a proposed memorandum of understanding between the city and McAlester Public Schools that could send $700,000 into the school coffers.

February 12, 2012
McAAP appoints director engineering, public works
Steven W. Cox, of McAlester, has been named director of engineering and public works at the McAlester Army Ammunition Plant, according to a Wednesday press release from McAAP.

February 12, 2012 1 Photo
PITTSBURG COUNTY DISTRICT COURT LOGS
The following felony and misdemeanor cases were decided in Pittsburg County District Court Feb. 1 - 6.

February 12, 2012
Local singer ready to go national
Singer Joanie Brooks has a song in her heart — and she’s ready to share it with the nation.

February 11, 2012 2 Photos
School elections set Tuesday in McAlester and other school districts
School elections are set for Tuesday in four school districts in Pittsburg County, with the county election board also assisting with a race in neighboring Pushmataha County.

February 11, 2012 4 Photos
Pride honors volunteers
Pride in McAlester held its third annual volunteer banquet at the Whistle Stop Bistro in Northtown on Thursday night

February 11, 2012 1 Photo
Parents and DHS: What are your rights?
When an investigator from Child Protective Services from the Oklahoma Department of Human Services comes to the door, most parents don’t know what their rights are. That’s according to some McAlester residents who have recently dealt with CPS.

February 11, 2012 2 Photos
McAlester New-Capital's junior reporters tell all
Globe-trotting, from McAlester to Japan

On Feb. 6, I had the pleasure of meeting two of the Harlem Globetrotters. Handles, who is 6’ 1,” wasn’t very tall compared to Stretch, who is 7’ 2”. ...

Living the dream

On Monday, the Harlem Globetrotters came to McAlester to play some basketball. Before the game, I had the honor to interview center “Stretch” Middleton and guard “Handles” Franklin. ...

February 10, 2012 6 Photos 1 Story
Shelter Documentary

On Thursdaythe Good Samaritan Outreach Shelter for Men was featured in a documentary by the First United Methodist Church in McAlester. Pictured from left is Thursday. Pictured from left is Chris Symes associate pastor of the First Methodist Church, Stephen LeFlore shelter director and Bill Derichsweiler shelter treasurer.

February 9, 2012 1 Photo
Man involved with recent meth lab explosion pleads guilty
A McAlester man who was recently involved with a local meth lab explosion pleaded guilty Friday in Pittsburg County District Court.

February 9, 2012 4 Photos
More Local News Headlines

It's awards season? Which 85th Academy Award nominated movie for Best Picture is your fave?

Local News

Search Results

Embattled judge defends his record

It's awards season? Which 85th Academy Award nominated movie for Best Picture is your fave?

Site Map

Contact Us